Landscapes of extended ruralisation: postcolonial suburbs in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania
Claire Mercer
Department of Geography and Environment, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, WC2A 2AE
Search for more papers by this authorClaire Mercer
Department of Geography and Environment, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, WC2A 2AE
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
African cities are becoming increasingly suburban, yet we know little about suburban spaces, how they are historically produced and by whom. This paper argues that African suburbs can be usefully understood as postcolonial suburbs. The postcolonial suburb de-centres the Anglo-American suburban model and pays attention to the historical co-constitution of suburban space across colony and metropole. It draws attention to the colonial and post-colonial policies on land and housing that make suburban development possible, but also attends to the everyday ways in which suburban spaces are built through the efforts of self-builders and their house-building projects. Using the case of Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, the paper shows how these low-density residential spaces towards the edge of the city are being shaped by the new middle classes with their appetite for large houses and private cars. But these are not copies of suburban forms from elsewhere. Architecturally they are dominated by bungalows and villas, but these buildings are self-built rather than part of large planned housing schemes. Socially the suburbs are dominated by the middle classes, but these middle classes are oriented towards the countryside rather than towards the city. Drawing on interviews with suburban residents in Dar es Salaam, I show how self-build housing projects straddle the suburban and the rural in terms of economic investments, land security and social relations. The paper concludes by arguing that the colonial and postcolonial making of the suburbs produces landscapes of ruralisation.
References
- Ally B 2015 State and market in urban land conflicts: the case of Dar es Salaam city, Tanzania: 1995–2015 Unpublished PhD thesis University of Dar es Salaam
- Archer J 1997 Colonial suburbs in South Asia, 1700–1850, and the spaces of modernity in R Silverstone ed Visions of suburbia Routledge, London 26–54
- Archer J 1998 Ideology and aspiration: individualism, the middle class, and the genesis of the Anglo-American suburb Journal of Urban History 14 214–53
- Bass Warner S 1962 Streetcar suburbs: the process of growth in Boston, 1870–1900 Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA
- Bhabha H 1994 The location of culture Routledge, New York
- Bloch R 2015 Africa's new suburbs in P Hamel and R Keil eds Suburban governance: a global view University of Toronto Press, Toronto 253–77
10.3138/9781442663565-016 Google Scholar
- Brennan J 2012 Taifa: making nation and race in urban Tanzania Ohio University Press, Athens OH
- Brennan J and Burton A 2007 The emerging metropolis: a history of Dar es Salaam, circa 1862–2000 in J Brennan, A Burton and Y Lawi eds Dar es Salaam: histories for an emerging African metropolis Mkuki na Nyota, Dar es Salaam 13–75
- Brenner N and Schmid C 2015 Towards a new epistemology of the urban? City 19 151–82
10.1080/13604813.2015.1014712 Google Scholar
- Brenner N and Schmid C 2013 Planetary urbanization International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 37 909–22
- Briggs J 2011 The land formalization process and the peri-urban zone of Dar es Salaam Planning Theory and Practice 12 115–53
- Briggs J and Mwamfupe D 2000 ‘Peri-urban development in an era of structural adjustment in Africa: the city of Dar es Salaam, Tanzania Urban Studies 37 797–809
- Buire C 2014 The dream and the ordinary: an ethnographic investigation of suburbanization in Luanda African Studies 73 290–312
- Burton A 2005 African underclass: urbanisation, crime and colonial order in Dar es Salaam James Currey, Oxford
- Campbell P F 2014 ‘The shack becomes the house, the slum becomes the suburb and the slum dweller becomes the citizen’: experiencing abandon and seeking legitimacy in Dar es Salaam Unpublished PhD thesis University of Glasgow
- Chakrabarty D 2000 Provincialising Europe Duke University Press, Durham NC
- Clapson M and Hutchison M eds 2010 Suburbanization in global society Research in Urban Sociology vol 10 Emerald, Bingley 1–14
10.1108/S1047-0042(2010)0000010003 Google Scholar
- Dancer H 2015 Women, land and justice in Tanzania James Currey, Woodbridge
10.1017/9781782045205 Google Scholar
- Davis M 2006 Planet of slums Verso, London
10.1111/j.1540-5842.2006.00797.x Google Scholar
- de Boeck F 2011a Spectral Kinshasa: building the city through an architecture of words in T Edensor and M Jayne eds Urban theory beyond the west: a world of cities Routledge, Abingdon 309–26
- de Boeck F 2011b Inhabiting ocular ground: Kinshasa's future in the light of Congo's spectral urban politics Cultural Anthropology 26 263–86
- de Jong K 2014 New suburbanisms Routledge, London
- Dill B 2013 Fixing the African state: recognition, politics and community-based development in Tanzania Palgrave, New York
10.1057/9781137281418 Google Scholar
- Driver F and Gilbert D 1998 Heart of empire? Landscape, space and performance in imperial London Environment and Planning A 16 11–28
- Duncan J and Duncan N 2004 Landscapes of privilege: the politics of the aesthetic in an American suburb Routledge, Abingdon
- Dwyer C, Gilbert D and Shah B 2013 Faith and suburbia: secularisation, modernity and the changing geographies of religion in London's suburbs Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 38 403–19
- Dyos H J 1961 Victorian suburb: a study of the growth of Camberwell University of Leicester Press, Leicester
- Ekers M, Hamel P and Keil R 2012 Governing suburbia: modalities and mechanisms of suburban governance Regional Studies 46 405–22
- Elleh N 1996 African architecture: evolution and transformation McGraw Hill, New York
- Ferguson J 1999 Expectations of modernity: myths and meanings of urban life on the Zambian Copperbelt University of California Press, Oakland CA
10.1525/9780520922280 Google Scholar
- Fishman R 1987 Bourgeois utopias: the rise and fall of suburbia Basic Books, New York NY
- Fleischer F 2010 Suburban Beijing: housing and consumption in contemporary China University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis MN
- Folkers A 2009 Modern architecture in Africa Sun, Amsterdam
- Freund W 2007 The African city: a history Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
- Geschiere P and Gugler J 1998 The urban-rural connection: changing issues of belonging and identification Africa 68 390–419
- Ghertner D A 2014 India's urban revolution: geographies of displacement beyond gentrification Environment and Planning A 46 1554–71
- Gilbert D and Driver F 2000 Capital and empire: geographies of imperial London GeoJournal 51 23–32
10.1023/A:1010897127759 Google Scholar
- Gough K and Yankson P W 2000a Land markets in African cities: the case of peri-urban Accra, Ghana Urban Studies 37 2485–500
- Gillen J 2016 Bringing the countryside to the city: practices and imaginations of the rural in Ho Chi Minh city, Vietnam Urban Studies 53 324–37
- Gluckman M 1958 Analysis of a social situation in modern Zululand Manchester University Press, Manchester
- Gough K and Yankson P K 2000b A neglected aspect of the housing market: the caretakers of peri-urban Accra, Ghana Urban Studies 37 2485–500
- Grant R 2007 Geographies of investment: how do the wealthy build new houses in Accra, Ghana? Urban Forum 18 31–59
10.1007/BF02681230 Google Scholar
- Hamel P and Keil R 2015 Introduction: governance in a suburban world in P Hamel and R Keil eds Suburban governance: a global view University of Toronto Press, Toronto 3–16
10.7202/1033834ar Google Scholar
- Harris R 1996 Unplanned suburbs: Toronto's American tragedy 1900 to 1950 Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore MD
- Harris R 1998 The silence of the experts: ‘aided self-help housing’, 1939–1954 Habitat International 22 165–89
- Harris R 2004 Creeping conformity: how Canada became suburban 1900–1960 University of Toronto Press, Toronto
- Harris R 2010 Meaningful types in a world of suburbs in M Clapson and R Hutchison eds Suburbanization in global society Research in Urban Sociology vol 10 Emerald, Bingley 15–47
10.1108/S1047-0042(2010)0000010004 Google Scholar
- Harris R and Larkham P J eds 1999 Changing suburbs: foundation, form and function E & FN Spon, London
- Hart K 1971 Migration and tribal identity among the Frafras of Ghana Journal of Asian and African Studies 6 21–6
- Herzog L A 2014 Global suburbs: urban sprawl from the Rio Grande to Rio de Janeiro Routledge, London
- Holston J 2008 Insurgent citizenship: disjunctions of democracy in Brazil Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ
- Home R 2004 Outside de Soto's bell jar: colonial/postcolonial land law and the exclusion of the peri-urban poor in R Home and H Lim eds Demystifying the mystery of capital: land tenure and poverty in Africa and the Caribbean Cavendish Publishing, London 11–30
- Home R 2014 Shaping cities of the global south: legal histories of planning and colonialism in S Parnell and S Oldfield eds The Routledge handbook on cities of the Global South Routledge, London 75–85
- Jackson K 1985 Crabgrass frontier: the suburbanization of the United States OUP, Oxford
10.1017/CBO9780511625503 Google Scholar
- Jazeel T 2014 Subaltern geographies: geographical knowledge and postcolonial strategy Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 35 88–103
- Jenkins P 2013 Urbanization, urbanism, and urbanity in an African city: home spaces and house cultures Palgrave Macmillan, New York
10.1057/9781137380173 Google Scholar
- King A D 1984 The bungalow: the production of a global culture Routledge and Kegan Paul, London
- King A D 2004 Spaces of global cultures: architecture, urbanism, identity Routledge, London
10.4324/9780203483121 Google Scholar
- Kironde J M L 1991 Sites-and-services in Tanzania: the case of Sinza, Kijitonyama and Mikocheni areas in Dar es Salaam Habitat International 15 27–38
10.1016/0197-3975(91)90004-5 Google Scholar
- Kironde J M L 2006 The regulatory framework, unplanned development and urban poverty: findings from Dar es Salaam, Tanzania Land Use Policy 23 460–72
- Kironde J M L 2007 Race, class and housing in Dar es Salaam: the colonial impact on land use structure 1891–1971 in J Brennan and A Burton eds Dar es Salaam: histories for an emerging African metropolis Mkuki na Nyota, Dar es Salaam 97–117
- Kombe W J 2000 Regularizing housing land development during the transition to market-let supply in Tanzania Habitat International 24 167–84
- Kombe W J 2005 Land use dynamics in peri-urban areas and their implications on the urban growth and form: the case of Dar es Salaam, Tanzania Habitat International 29 113–35
- Kombe W J 2010 Land acquisition for public use, emerging conflicts and their socio-political implications International Journal of Urban Sustainable Development 2 45–63
10.1080/19463138.2010.520919 Google Scholar
- Kombe W J and Kreibich V 2000 Informal land management in Tanzania SPRING Research Series No 29, University of Dortmund
- Krause M 2013 The ruralisation of the world Public Culture 25 233–48
- Landau L B 2014 Conviviality, rights and conflict in Africa's urban estuaries Politics and Society 42 359–80
- Lefebvre H 2003 [1970] The urban revolution Bonono R trans University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis MN
- Lemanski C 2006 Residential responses to fear (of crime plus) in two Cape Town suburbs: implications for the post-apartheid city Journal of International Development 18 787–802
10.1002/jid.1314 Google Scholar
- Mabin A 2005 Suburbanisation, segregation, and government of territorial transformations Transformation 57 41–63
10.1353/trn.2005.0030 Google Scholar
- Mabin A, Butcher S and Bloch R 2013 Peripheries, suburbanisms and change in sub-Saharan Africa cities Social Dynamics: A Journal of African Studies 39 167–90
- Mace A 2013 City suburbs: placing suburbia in a post-suburban world Routledge, London
10.4324/9780203066720 Google Scholar
- Mamdani M 1996 Citizen and subject: contemporary Africa and the legacy of late colonialism Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ
- Mbiba B and Huchzermeyer M 2002 Contentious development: peri-urban studies in sub-Saharan Africa Progress in Development Studies 2 113–31
10.1191/1464993402ps032ra Google Scholar
- McFarlane C 2011 The city as a machine for learning Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 36 360–76
- McGregor D, Simon D and Thompson D 2006 The peri-urban interface: approaches to sustainable natural and human resource use Earthscan, London
- McLees L 2011 Access to land for urban farming in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania: histories, benefits and insecure tenure Journal of Modern African Studies 49 601–24
- Melly C 2010 Inside-out houses: urban belonging and imagined futures in Dakar, Senegal Comparative Studies in Society and History 52 37–65
- Mercer C 2014 Middle class construction: domestic architecture, aesthetics and anxieties in Tanzania Journal of Modern African Studies 52 227–50
- Mercer C, Page B and Evans M 2008 Development and the African diaspora: place and the politics of home Zed, London
10.5040/9781350219557 Google Scholar
- Merrifield A 2013 The urban question under planetary urbanization Public Culture 25 85–114
- Miele C 1999 From aristocratic ideal to middle-class idyll: 1690–1840 in A Saint ed London suburbs Merrell Holberton, London
- Mignolo W 2011 The darker side of modernity: global futures, decolonial options Duke University Press, Durham NC
10.1215/9780822394501 Google Scholar
- Miller D 2005 New regional imaginaries in post-Apartheid Southern Africa – retail workers at a shopping mall in Zambia Journal of Southern African Studies 31 117–45
- Molohan M J B 1959 Detribalization: a study of the areas of Tanganyika where detribalized persons are living with recommendations as the administrative and other measures required to meet the problems arising therein Government Printer, Dar es Salaam
- Morange M, Folio F, Peyroux E and Vivet J 2012 The spread of a transnational model: ‘gated communities’ in three Southern African cities (Cape Town, Maputo and Windhoek) International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 36 890–914
- Msangi D 2011 Land acquisition for urban expansion: process and impacts on livelihoods of peri urban households, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania Unpublished Licentiate thesis Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala
- Myers G A 2003a Verandahs of power: colonialism and space in urban Africa Syracuse University Press, New York NY
- Myers G A 2003b Designing power: forms and purposes of colonial model neighbourhoods in British Africa Habitat International 27 193–204
- Myers G A 2011 African cities: alternative visions of urban theory and practice Zed Books, London
10.5040/9781350218123 Google Scholar
- Myers G A 2014 From expected to unexpected comparisons: changing the flows of ideas about cities in a postcolonial urban world Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 35 104–18
- Myers G A 2015 Remaking the edges: surveillance and flows in sub-Saharan Africa's new suburbs in A Luescher and C Loeb eds The design of frontier spaces: control and ambiguity Ashgate, Aldershot 45–63
- Nayak A 2010 Race, affect and emotion: young people, racism and graffiti in the postcolonial English suburbs Environment and Planning A 42 2370–92
- Owens G R 2004 On the edge of a city: an historical ethnography of urban identity in the northwestern suburbs of Dar es Salaam, Tanzania Unpublished PhD thesis University of Wisconsin-Madison
- Owens G R 2010 Post-colonial migration: virtual culture, urban farming and new peri-urban growth in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, 1975–2000 Africa 80 249–74
- Padawangi R 2010 The planned suburbanization of a city-state: Singapore's new towns in M Clapson and R Hutchison eds Suburbanization in global society Research in Urban Sociology vol 10 Emerald, Bingley 293–318
10.1108/S1047-0042(2010)0000010015 Google Scholar
- Parnell S and Hart D 1999 Self-help housing as a flexible instrument of state control in 20th-century South Africa Housing Studies 14 367–86
- Peil M 1981 Cities and suburbs: urban life in West Africa Africana Publishing, London
- Phelps N and Wu F eds 2011 International perspectives on suburbanization: a post-suburban world? Palgrave, London
10.1057/9780230308626 Google Scholar
- Phelps N, Wood A and Valler D 2010 A post-suburban world? An outline of a research agenda Environment and Planning A 42 366–83
- Pieterse E and Parnell S 2014 Africa's urban revolution in context in S Parnell and E Pieterse eds Africa's urban revolution Zed, London 1–17
- Piot C 1999 Remotely global: village modernity in West Africa University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
10.7208/chicago/9780226189833.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Potts D 2010 Circular migration in Zimbabwe and contemporary sub-Saharan Africa James Currey, Oxford
- Potts D 2012 What do we know about urbanization in sub-Saharan Africa and does it matter? International Development Planning Review 34 v–xxi
- Quayson A 2012 The sighs of history: postcolonial debris and the question of (literary) history New Literary History 43 359–70
- Rizzo M 2017 Taken for a ride: grounding neoliberalism, precarious labour and public transport in an African metropolis Oxford University Press, Oxford
- Robinson J 2003 Postcolonialising geography: tactics and pitfalls Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 24 273–89
- Robinson J 2011 Cities in a world of cities: the comparative gesture International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 35 1–23
- Roitman S 2010 The changing image of suburban areas in Latin America and the role of local government in M Clapson and R Hutchison eds Suburbanization in global society Research in Urban Sociology vol. 10 Emerald, Bingley 273–92
10.1108/S1047-0042(2010)0000010014 Google Scholar
- Roy A 2011 Slumdog cities: rethinking subaltern urbanism International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 35 223–38
- Roy A 2015 Governing the postcolonial suburbs in P Hamel and R Keil eds Suburban governance: a global view University of Toronto Press, Toronto 337–47
10.3138/9781442663565-020 Google Scholar
- Roy A 2016 What is critical about critical urban theory? Urban Geography 37 810–23
- Sawyer L 2014 Piecemeal urbanization at the peripheries of Lagos African Studies 73 271–89
- Schroeder R 2012 Africa after apartheid: South Africa, race and nation in Tanzania Indiana University Press, Bloomington IN
- Shivji I 1998 Not yet democracy: reforming land tenure in Tanzania International Institute for Environment and Development, HAKIARDHI and Faculty of Law, University of Dar es Salaam
- Silverstone R 1997 Introduction in R Silverstone ed Visions of suburbia Routledge, London 1–25
- Simon D 2008 Urban environments: issues on the peri-urban fringe Annual Review of Environment and Resources 33 167–85
- Simon D, McGregor D and Nsiah-Gyabaah K 2004 The changing urban-rural interface of African cities: definitional issues and an application to Kumasi, Ghana Environment and Urbanization 16 235–48
- Simone A M 2010 City life from Jakarta to Dakar: movements at the crossroads Routledge, London
10.4324/9780203892497 Google Scholar
- Smiley S L 2009 The city of three colors: segregation in colonial Dar es Salaam, 1891–1961 Historical Geography 37 178–96
- Stoler A L 2008 Imperial debris: reflections on ruins and ruination Cultural Anthropology 23 191–219
- Sundet G 1997 The politics of land in Tanzania Unpublished DPhil thesis Exeter College, University of Oxford
- Tacoli C ed 2006 The Earthscan reader in rural-urban linkages Earthscan, Abingdon
- Tang W-S 2014 When Lefebvre meets the East: urbanization in Hong Kong in Ł Stanek, C Schmid and A Moravanszky eds 2014 Urban revolution now: Henri Lefebvre in social research and architecture Ashgate, Aldershot 71–92
- Teaford J 1979 City and suburb: the political fragmentation of metropolitan America, 1850–1970 Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore MD
- Teaford J 1996 Post-suburbia: government and politics in the edge cities Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore MD
- Teaford J 2007 The American suburb: the basics Routledge, Abingdon
- Teaford J 2011 Suburbia and post-suburbia: a brief history in N Phelps and F Wu eds International perspectives on suburbanization: a post-suburban world? Palgrave, London 15–34
10.1057/9780230308626_2 Google Scholar
- Todes A 2014 New African suburbanisation? Exploring the growth of the northern corridor of eThekwini/KwaDakuza African Studies 73 245–70
- Trager L 2001 Yoruba hometowns: community, identity and development in Nigeria Lynne Rienner, Boulder CO
- Trefon T 2011 Urban–rural straddling: conceptualizing the peri-urban in Central Africa Journal of Developing Societies 27 431–43
10.1177/0169796X1102700408 Google Scholar
- UN-Habitat 2010a The state of African cities 2010: governance, inequality and urban land markets United Nations Human Settlements Programme, Nairobi
- UN-Habitat 2010b Citywide action plan for upgrading unplanned and unserviced settlements in Dar es Salaam United Nations Human Settlements Programme, Nairobi
- UN-Habitat 2014 The state of African cities 2014: re-imagining sustainable urban transitions United Nations Human Settlements Programme, Nairobi
- Vaughan L, Griffiths S, Haklay M and Jones E C 2009 Do the suburbs exist? Discovering complexity and specificity in suburban built form Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 34 475–88
- Veloso L 2010 Governing heterogeneity in the context of ‘compulsory closeness’: the ‘pacification’ of favelas in Rio de Janeiro in M Clapson and R Hutchison eds Suburbanization in global society Research in Urban Sociology vol 10 Emerald, Bingley 253–72
10.1108/S1047-0042(2010)0000010013 Google Scholar
- Walks A 2013 Suburbanism as a way of life, slight return Urban Studies 50 1471–88
- Watson V 2013 African urban fantasies: dreams or nightmares? Environment and Urbanization 26 1–17
- Yeboah I E A 2005 Housing the urban poor in twenty-first century sub-Saharan Africa: policy mismatch and a way forward for Ghana GeoJournal 62 147–61
10.1007/s10708-005-8182-x Google Scholar
- Young R C 2012 Postcolonial remains New Literary History 43 19–42